12/06/07 - Article - Safety actuator and a second-generation Safety Monitor: Follow up to the HMI2007: (R)Evolution for Safety at Work




Safety actuator and a second-generation Safety Monitor

Follow up to the HMI2007: (R)Evolution for Safety at Work


The activities around Safety at Work may be called Evolution or Revolution: Fact is, it is becoming considerably more user-friendly. The Safety Monitor becomes intelligent and enables the user to request all safety related network data locally. All diagnostic data can now be transferred from the Safety Monitor to the master and the application program, and the user gains a space and expense advantage if the Safety Monitor with integrated gateway to PROFIBUS is used. And safety actuators continue to simplify the construction of Safety at Work networks.

 

Fig. 1: The new Safety Monitor in Stainless Steel by Bihl+Wiedemann


In 1999 AS-Interface introduced "Safety at Work", the first bus system being able to simultaneously handle standard and safety-oriented devices on a single network. The goal of this design was to eliminate the previously hard wired safety-oriented applications by a bus technology without the need to introducing an additional safety bus. Standard and safety-oriented components should be connected by the simple two-conductor cable that made AS-Interface such a success. Additionally, the system was not only supposed to be fully compatible with all existing slaves but also, because of the wide-ranged usage possibilities of AS-Interface, with all masters and gateways that were already available and not safety-oriented by themselves. This standard compliant solution, approved by regulatory agencies for usage in applications up to category 4/SIL 3, was implemented by using separate safety contacts and controlling them by a safety monitor. The Safety Monitor interfaces the safe inputs, supervises their communications, and stops the application if the "STOP" signal is sent. The Safety Monitor is constructed as a safe device and runs the safety configuration. This configuration is created by the "ASIMON" PC application and then downloaded to the Safety Monitor. This principal permits the design of safety-oriented applications on the lowest field level without the necessity for master or control system to be implemented safety-oriented by themselves.

Safety at Work was proven to be effective in numerous applications during the past 7 years. But like in most cases: "The proof of the pudding is in the eating": Field experience leads to requests for new functionalities and the latest AS-Interface specification 3.0 permits the realization of new ideas. Bihl+Wiedemann reacted to these requests and developed a second-generation Safety Monitor (fig.1).



A safe output for OEM applications for Safety at Work

Fig. 2: AS-i Safety
output in IP20
Safe outputs for Safety at Work are used as "remote outputs" of the Safety Monitor (figure 2). They offer two important advantages: the outputs can be implemented at arbitrary locations in the system without the need for additional wiring between the Safety Monitor and the location where the safe shutdown is needed. Also, multiple safe outputs can share the same safe address due to the unique communication method. This enables grouping of outputs for the application.





The new Safety Monitor

Since many new features distinguish this new Bihl+Wiedemann's Safety Monitor, it makes sense to call it "second generation" device. It is based on the well-established stainless steel housing this manufacturer is known for (fig.1):
  1. Diagnosis data of the new Safety Monitor:

    RUN / Stop / Offline phase

    Number of the released circuit during a stop condition

    Address of the initiating slave

    Detailed information concerning the cause of the STOP:
    Operational-related STOP (STOP without a null sequence)
    Error-related STOP = STOP because of an error (code error, slave failure, etc.)
    iInternal device error
    History (last STOP cause) retrievable

    Condition of the network:
    Erdschluss
    Ground fault
    Supply voltage interruption
    Over voltage
    Double address detection
    Failed (standard) slave
    Error counter per slave retrievable
    Actual slave conditions retrievable
    Restart conditions:
    Restart
    Reset of error condition
    Check necessary
    The most important: The monitor has a display and keyboard enabling the user to execute new and detailed diagnosis possibilities (see table) offering considerable support during the design phase of the system as well as during the maintenance and trouble shooting phase when the cause for a STOP must be determined quickly. The previous logical and local separation of information across the system, always considered annoying, is now rendered unnecessary. A PC and the "ASIMON" software are no longer necessary to determine the reasons for a sudden STOP of the system. This is especially important if users without detailed background knowledge operate the system.
    users without detailed background knowledge operate the system. However, the parallel method of transferring data via the RS232 to a PC is still available and thus permits the programming of the Safety Monitor. As before it is still possible to display the behavior of all safe slaves graphically.
  2. The Safety Monitor is implemented as a slave in its network. Due to specification 3.0 enhancements it is now possible to "up link" all diagnostic data from the Safety Monitor to the PLC and application program via the AS-Interface network. All it takes is a master built according to specification 3.0 (independent of the manufacturer). This feature becomes especially important if the data is also needed by the upper level control system.
  3. This way all diagnostic data is available at three different locations: locally on the Safety Monitor display, on the optionally connected PC (providing the option to print the data), and on the (potentially far away) control systems. Hence, the user has the choice of where he/she wants to check the system: at the Safety Monitor (in the field) or at the central control system. This represents the inclusion of the detailed error diagnostics first introduced by Bihl+Wiedemann into AS-Interface Safety at Work.
    (The formerly used Safety Monitor displayed current conditions only by using LEDs since it did not make sense to generate diagnostic data that could not be transmitted to the master in its entirety. Consequently, it was often necessary to diagnose a system by using a PC.)
  4. The new Monitor is able to create a safety message for a second AS-Interface network. It does not only supervise safety devices on its own network but can also function as a safety slave on a second Safety at Work network. Thus it is easy and inexpensive to transmit safety information about the condition of the first into a second network.
  5. The new Safety Monitor supports now safety outputs. Safety at Work is not limited to safety inputs any more.
  6. Fig. 3: Memory Card
    The configurations saved in the monitor can now be changed by replacing memory cards. This simplifies support by the machine builder or system modifications. Service calls are therefore considerably reduced.
  7. The advanced AS-Interface diagnostics features, well know from the Bihl+Wiedemann1 masters, were added: error counter, ground fault detection, double address detection, noise monitoring, and over voltage indication. These diagnostic methods offer additional support during error diagnostics, operational tests at set-up and service.
  8. The new Safety Monitor can be powered from the AS-Interface network, while the previous generation Safety Monitor had to be powered by a (separate) 24 V supply. Additionally, it is possible to redundantly power the system from a 24 V supply or a second AS-Interface network in such a way that failure (for instance due to a short circuit) does not lead to a loss of information about the condition and the history of the Safety Monitor. This facilitates the analysis of the problem causing this fault.



Safety Monitor with integrated PROFIBUS Gateway

Fig. 4: Safety monitor
with integrated
PROFIBUS gateway
Especially for PROFIBUS networks there is another simplification: An AS-i 3.0 PROFIBUS gateway with integrated Safety Monitor, also in a stainless steel housing, is offered. This gateway allows access to all application functions, including those that are not safety related, plus ensures the PC programming at the location of the gateway. Prerequisite for using this gateway is only that it is possible to place master and monitor at the same location without separating them, for instance, by a repeater. If this condition is fulfilled the gateway represents the most elegant solution offering space and cost advantages in addition to user friendliness.



Interoperability and compatibility

What remains as strong as always are interoperability and compatibility, the well-known foundations of AS-Interface. Naturally, the new Safety Monitor in the stainless steel housing and the new gateway with integrated monitor can be used with all safety-related slaves and modules, independent of their manufacturers. However, interoperability includes more than the hardware: both devices can load and execute any already existing configuration running on a Safety Monitor of the first generation!
During normal operation the stainless steel Safety Monitor operates as a specification compliant 3.0 slave with the profile "combined transactions" and is interoperable with any 3.0 master and thus with any control system interfaced via an upper level network. However, it is downward compatible as well: It can operate as a Safety Monitor in networks with older masters according to specification 2.0 or 2.1. If used as a replacement component in such network or for its easy error evaluation the Safety Monitor can be configured as a simple 2.1 slave. In this case the PLC application runs as before, without modifications of the master or application program. Only the transmission of data using the new profile is not possible.
Both, interoperability and compatibility are considered important factors with respect to protecting the users investment in previously developed safety technology solutions.




  1. Madelung, O.W.: The new master generation of B+W: Double addresses? - The problem has been solved!. SPS Magazin, issue 12, Decembre 2003, p. 77-79

Article as PDF file


[back]